Saturday, 19 May 2012

Was Durai an effective leader?

What happened in National Kidney Foundation shocked Singapore. It also caused collateral damage to the whole non-profit sector by diminishing people’s trust in NGOs.
Durai was an effective leader in many ways. Under his leadership, NKF grew from a tiny group into the nation’s largest foundation. By the time Durai was sacked, a large number of kidney patients in Singapore relied on NKF. A large number of donor and large amounts of donations indicated the trust Durai earned. Inside the organization, Durai earned so much respect and loyalty of his employees. Even after he was found guilty of misappropriations, his employees continued to regard him as a true leader. Therefore, from the perspective of some of his employees, Durai was a true leader. 

However, a leader should not be judged by his team alone. Especially, in non-profit organizations, bringing prosperity to one’s own team should never be the goal. Durai fell short of characteristics of an effective leader in some aspects. First, he created so much cohesiveness in NKF which led team members into group think. They ultimately failed to evaluate their own behaviors against ethical standards. Durai also failed to consider donors and patients as his followers which he needed to take care. 

Second, one can argue that he was a hypocrite. He was described as “a leader who took accountability serious”. $30 fine to staff for forgetting to turn off the lights! And yet, he finally ended up with unethical behaviors and making huge personal gains from donations at the expense of patients. However, people may change over time to a shocking extent. For example, Senior General Than Shwe, former chief of Myanmar’s brutal military junta was known to be a humble person who did not pursue material wealth in his early days. Some people who knew him as a captain described – “He lived in a small house with no frill lifestyle. He was very soft spoken, simple and kind. He did not seek any privilege unlike most army officers did.” I wonder if Professor Zimbardo might describe this as a Lucifer Effect. Myanmar people usually say, “Power spoils most people.” I believe Durai had gone through similar process of escalating authority in the organization together with the growing sense of invulnerability. 

Although he might be an effective leader, Durai lacks humility and professional will described by Jim Collins as unique qualities of level 5 leaders. He could be a level 4 leader at best. 

To me, Durai appears to be a Narcissist as well. He even sued people who tried to point out his unethical behaviors. One might even say that he led NKF into corporate narcissism in which the members were extremely loyal to organization rather than stakeholders. Actually, this is not unusual in NGOs and UN agencies, according to my experience. 

So, was Durai an effective leader? I would say “May be for a handful of his followers who wanted to make personal gains. Definitely not for NKF and stakeholders.”

2 comments:

  1. Thanks for this insightful post. Leadership to me, is often not just about effective to achieve a certain goal. For me, a good leader is also about values and the worthiness of the goals/objective the leadership seek to achieve.

    For example, in the mafia, the mafia boss can also be an effective leader. So can Hilter be deemed as one too. But are they truly leaders? or simply misguided leaders?

    I like your point about the Lucifer Effect and that is why I believe there must be checks and balances in everything.. not because there is no trust but because we want to make sure we can continue to trust. A powerful leader who are able to silence his/her critics, let him/her take heed, lest he/she fall.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You raised the point about Durai being a narcissist, which seems to be true. While I believe that all leaders need a dash of narcissism and that narcissistic leaders have the courage to drive considerable changes; the trick is to convert the narcissistic tendencies into fruitful use. This is where Durai seems to have failed. Narcissism in leadership can turn fruitless if leader lacks self-awareness, is driven by egotism and the desire for supremacy and veneration. Even the most brilliant narcissist leaders are distrusted in such circumstances.

    ReplyDelete